Off-the-Beaten-Path
For guests seeking a slice of the island that feels a little more secret, here are five local favorites that capture the heart of St. Thomas.
1.
Mermaids Chair
A narrow sandbar where two seas meet, Mermaids Chair feels like a secret edge of the island. The walk in is part of the adventure, with sweeping views and crashing surf on both sides once you arrive.
2.
Coral World
An easy way to get face-to-face with the underwater world without a dive certification. Walk through aquariums, touch pools, and an underwater observatory to see reef life up close, then step right out to the beach.
3.
Greengos Café
A colorful little spot that feels more like a local hangout than a tourist stop. Expect strong drinks, bold flavors, and a laid-back vibe that makes it a fun place to refuel between island adventures.
4.
Bingo at The Shack
A casual, come-as-you-are bingo night where visitors mix with locals. It’s less about the prizes and more about the laughs, the commentary, and the chance to see a slice of everyday island life.
5.
Lobster Night at Duffy’s
On lobster night, Duffy’s turns into a lively feast. Fresh grilled lobster, island sides, and a party atmosphere make it feel like a weekly celebration rather than just another dinner out.